Txiki Begiristain and Pep Guardiola have five reasons to worry as they chase the new Man City striker – Alex Brotherton

It’s that time of year again …

As we climb towards the end of the twilight zone, which is the period between Christmas Day and New Year’s Day, the minds of every football fan are preoccupied with their club’s potential January transfer business.

With Pep Guardiola at the helm, Manchester City fans have gotten used to quiet January – only Gabriel Jesus and Aymeric Laporte have arrived halfway through the season during Pep’s time as coach.

Nevertheless, City’s goals remain a major topic of conversation with a busy summer on the horizon. With names like Erling Haaland and Dusan Vlahovic flying around, we thought we would bring things down to earth again by remembering the transfer forks that Guardiola and City’s football director Txiki Begiristain should avoid.

Eliaquim Mangala

In theory, the conquest of Eliaquim Mangala from Porto in the summer of 2014 should cost £ 40.5m. have been an excellent piece of business by Txiki.

The tall, strong and fast central defender was wanted by a host of top European clubs and looked like the ideal defensive partner for Vincent Kompany.

His debut, a home game against Chelsea in which he bullied Diego Costa for 90 minutes, did nothing but reinforce this perception.

Thereafter, his City career was a train wreck.

Eliaquim Mangala failed to improve City’s leaky defense

Every ounce of football intelligence that the French national team player showed during his debut seemed to leave him as he was regularly found in the absence of more than five years in Manchester.

Following his release from Valencia this summer, the 30-year-old is now without a club.


Defensive midfielder Fernando followed Mangala to City from Porto the same summer, but he did a little better.

Maybe it was an unfair measure, but compared to Prime Fernandinho, he looked slow, heavy and without technical quality.

The two seasons in which he played most for City – 2014/15 and 2015/16 – were synonymous with defensive fragility, something he had to help solve.

Fernando had a hard time in the Premier League

However, his career since leaving City in 2017 suggests that his matches at Manchester were a blip. After moving to Galatasaray, the Brazilian joined Sevilla, where he played an integral role in the Spanish team winning the Europa League in 2020.

Wilfried Bony

The panic attack of all panic attacks.

In January 2015, Chelsea were ahead of the Premier League title, so with a roll of the dice, Txiki signed striker Wilfried Bony from Swansea City.

On paper, it should have been spent well over 28 million pounds – the Ivorian was a proven top scorer who could complement Sergio Aguero.

Wilfried Bony in his city days

But things did not work out, with Bony scoring just 11 goals in 46 appearances for the Blues.

Txiki must have learned a lot from the failure, as City have not made a last-minute panic attack since.


Like so many of City’s failed signings, Nolito looked pretty good in the beginning.

The Spanish winger brought a diligence and intensity that City’s attack had been lacking for some time, with three goals and two assists in his first five games for Guardiola’s team, which made a good impression.

MANCHESTER, ENGLAND - DECEMBER 6: Nolito from Manchester City is spoken to by his head coach / manager Pep Guardiola during the UEFA Champions League match between Manchester City FC and Celtic FC at the Etihad Stadium on December 6, 2016 in Manchester, England.  (Photo by James Baylis - AMA / Getty Images)
Nolito did not have the best times in City

Still, it quickly became apparent that the £ 16m man. was not of the quality of player that Guardiola wanted, both in terms of technical ability and temperament.

In the second half of the 2016/17 campaign, he barely played before being sent to Sevilla.

Claudio Bravo

Due to the fact that he was the guy to replace City legend Joe Hart, Claudio Bravo always had to face a battle to win over City fans. His performance in 2016/17 did not help at all.

Like you, we can not get enough of Manchester City! That is why we have decided to supplement our expansive city coverage Manchester Evening News with a more fan-oriented platform aimed specifically at City fans – The city is ours.

Writers and presenters who share your passion for the blue side of Manchester will produce written, visual and audio content to reflect the mood of the stands as well as the press box.

Follow our team on Twitter (@ DomFarrell1986 and @alex_brotherton)!

While Bravo was better with the ball at his feet than Hart – the main reason Guardiola brought him in – it seemed that every shot he faced escaped him. As some said at the time, he was the only goalkeeper in the world who made the goal look bigger.

After Ederson joined in 2017, Bravo was only involved in cup matches, but he managed to earn the City supporters’ love with penalty heroism in the League Cup and Community Shield.

But for his disastrous spell as City’s number one, he must be considered a flop.

Who do you think is the worst signing made during Guardiola’s and Begiristain’s time in City? Follow ours Town Is our author Alex Brotherton on Twitter to get involved in the discussion and give us your thoughts in the comments section below.


Leave a Comment